Former budget watchdog Page says Ottawa can't rag the puck on NATO 2035 spending math

Mark Carney unveiled a made-in-Canada defence procurement plan that has prompted skepticism from defence experts. Colton Praill explains why.

OTTAWA — Former federal spending watchdog Kevin Page remains unconvinced by the prime minister’s explanation of why Ottawa hasn’t yet presented a fiscal road map to meet the new NATO spending commitments.

Page, who was Canada’s first parliamentary budget officer and now heads the Institute of Fiscal Studies and Democracy at the University of Ottawa, said Ottawa has been not fiscally transparent with its math. He said Canada must soon show how it plans to significantly ramp up defence spending through to 2035.

NATO members met last year in The Hague and agreed to spending the equivalent of five per cent of GDP on defence by 2035. But federal fiscal updates have yet to chart the numbers that far out, past 2030 — something Page said should be spelled out this coming fall in the next budget.

“It’s a major question mark,” Page tells The Canadian Press in an interview, saying it raises uncertainty about how committed Canada is to meeting the targets after failing to hit the two per cent mark for so long. 

“How is Canada going to finance this, and will it be able to meet its targets as well?”

• READ MORE: ‘Critical equipment shortages’: Why the CAF is asking some staff to return field gear
• READ MORE: Canadian military to shutter Nanisivik naval facility in the Arctic

Prime Minister Mark Carney said earlier this week that if Ottawa put out a full plan last year, it would already be dated because of how quickly modern warfare is changing. 

He specifically pointed to the rapid advancements in drone and AI technology seen throughout the Ukraine war as a case-in-point, and said he wants to spend the funds wisely amid global uncertainty.

“There’s a couple of reasons why we don’t immediately specify that … and the core reason is we want to spend the money well,” Carney said on Tuesday, when asked by The Canadian Press to justify not yet producing a clear path to achieving five per cent by 2035.

“If we had sat down even in June last year and mapped out what, with all due respect, the armed forces would have thought how they would have spent 1.5 per cent of GDP on defence, it would have looked a lot like how they would have answered that question five years ago. We’re not going to do that.”

Carney also said the NATO alliance agreed the new spending targets would be reviewed in 2030 anyway.

But Page said the government can always adjust its figures as military procurement plans change, and public pressure will ramp up on Ottawa if the figures aren’t included in the fall budget.

“You can’t say that the reason I’m not going to give you a number is because I want to do it well. Does that fly with you? It doesn’t fly with me,” Page said.

“It’s a large part of the overall amount of spending and it’s the fastest growing part. I’d feel more confident in the government that we’re going to live up to commitments if I saw the allocation and plans.”

He said Canadians would reasonably assume the Carney government would change the allocations over time as plans adjust.

While Canada is under pressure from the Pentagon amid trade negotiations to show how it will meet the higher spending target, Page says Canadians deserve to know more about the government’s intentions because it raises questions about how Ottawa will bankroll it — such as by through growing the deficit, or hiking taxes.

Still, Ottawa insists it will meet the new targets. 

Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand told media in Helsingborg, Sweden on her way into meetings with her alliance counterparts Friday that Canada is “on track to meet five per cent of GDP by 2035” and remains “solid and united with our partners in NATO.”

• READ MORE: Canada falling short on defence spending, F-35 review, Pentagon official says
• READ MORE: Top military commander Gen. Carignan nominated for senior advisory role in NATO

This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 22, 2026.

Kyle Duggan, The Canadian Press